Sunday, January 15, 2006
In Bed With Aaron & Oscar
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a4b52/a4b52cc55358f4b7720abf841ba0540a1fce1e04" alt=""
I've been watching Best Picture Oscar winners. I've seen 6 in the past three days, nearly 15 hours of film-watching. I'd rank them, in order of artistic merit:
1. On The Waterfront (1954) - A+ - Gripping, gritty, grainy tale of corruption and conscience - perhaps Brando's finest hour - what facial expressions! what body language!
2. Best Years Of Our Lives (1946) - A+ - Coming home from war ain't easy. Dead-honest portrait of three returning servicemen facing re-adjustment problems, this film's unflinching take on class, disability, and relationships is far ahead of its time.
3. The Lost Weekend (1945) - A- - A trip to hell in the skin of an alcohol addict - how low you can go..
4. Hamlet (1948) - A- - Laurence Olivier directed and starred, cut out an hour of dialogue, and made the play more immediate and urgent on film - using cinema's specific tools of close-ups, location shots, and orchestral soundtrack...
5. How Green Was My Valley (1941) - B - Childhood memories of a Welsh mining town, masterfully re-created with sympathy for the plight of desperately hungry working men devoured by the wheels of industry (the world seems more complacent today about capitalism's nastier side-effects). Lots of singing and pathos, a crippled boy and star-crossed lovers. Plucking those heart-strings.
6. Gentlemen's Agreement (1947) - B- - Gregory Peck plays a journalist who pretends to be Jewish to get a story on anti-semitism and learns what thoughtless, cruel, scared rabbits we mortals can be. Well-meaning, but often feels contrived and preachy - odd that no great film of the day looked at the plight of African Americans with equivalent scrutiny... I should also admit that I've rarely been victim to anti-semitism, growing up in post-60s Jewish New York, whereas my parents were exposed to far more of it, during the era in which this film was made.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87b3f/87b3f6252ad2847b910602f643eab0f382e8a990" alt=""
this entry's permalink
Comments:
Post a Comment